I mean I could but why would I want to?
GIFT CARD + ACCOUTREMENTS
Gas gift card + custom glow-in-the-dark keychain

Fast food gift card + fancy candlesticks
For a romantic dinner In This Economy
Bookstore gift card + vintage bookends
eBay is your friend. May I suggestโฆ alabaster horse heads, midcentury slates, Japanese collie/wolf, Murano glass fruit (!!!), wooden mallards, glazed cats, logs, and/or a bull and matador. You canโt buy these sick lucite numbers though, โcause I beat ya to it!
FOR KIDS
Kids are just like us: self-obsessed. Nourish their narcissism by assigning them an animal equivalent, then sending along a note explaining why theyโre a kangaroo (โathletic, headstrong, punchy, cuteโ).
*I first beheld these on Cup of Jo!
Non-toys
It is my experience that little kids love mundane adult belongings. I think this is because the child brain automatically categorizes anything owned and operated by adults as Off-Limits & Therefore Tantalizing. Here are a few boring things children would be thrilled to have โtheir ownโ of: a set of keys, a flyswatter, a ream of paper, a clipboard, a flashlight, a dust-buster, a stethoscope, and/or a call bell. The โOBJECTSโ section of the emoji library is a fruitful resource.
Note: It is critical that the items not be PATRONIZING FABRICATIONS (i.e. toy versions) of grown-up stuff. They must be 100% autรฉntico.

A big box of balls
Self-explanatory!
Kiddie jackhammer* and floor puzzle (or other jackhammer-able surface)
Aka โDIY fracking playset,โ as coined by my friend Steph.
This is a working theory, but I believe the sanctioned demolition of an educational puzzle would 1) Motivate faster completion 2) Ingrain knowledge into the cranium of a child in a way rote memorization never could.
*An exception to the โno kiddie versionโ rule, for obvious reasons
NOVELTIES
Optional accoutrement: Luxury toothpaste
Optional accoutrement: Bougie rouge
Non-optional accoutrement: One AA battery

LEISURE KITS
The Winning Number Kit
A book that tells you which lucky numbers correspond to the subjects of your dreams + melatonin gummies (Lotto ticket sold separately.)
The Pyromaniac Kit
Personalized BIC lighter + whimsical candle (or pack of Pall Malls)
The Philately Kit
Personalized return address stamp + a sheet of fun stamps
Buyerโs bonus: Ordering stamps from the USPS website catalyzes a delightful phenomenonโgetting mail from the mail.
NOVEL APPROACHES TO BOOKS AS GIFTS
A book by their favorite authorโs favorite author
An ex-boyfriend once gave me a book by Eudora Welty because Eudora Welty was one of my favorite authorโs* favorite authors. The relationship perished, but the genius gifting hack (and love for Eudora Welty) lives on. You could also try a book by the recipientโs favorite athleteโs, musicianโs, or artistโs favorite author.
*Alice Munro
A book published the year they were born
A spousal double-feature, for two takes on one story
Everything But The Bookโข๏ธ
Bookends and a bookmark (or bookplates). Just Add Literature.
WHY DONโT YOU STUFF A STOCKING WITHโฆ
Or 400 glow-in-the-dark stars. Or 25 plastic chicken wings.
Happy holi-yays! ๐
P.S. You can see my (equally deranged) 2022 Gift Ideas here, if youโd like.